Prof. Ayelet Shavit

Prof. Ayelet Shavit
אילת שביט
Accordion Title Biographical Info

Biographical Info

I am a philosopher of science, chair of the “Action-Oriented Philosophy” department at Tel Hai College, Research Fellow at the Technion and the recipient of the “PSA Outreach and Engagement Award”, “Van Leer Prize”, “Bloomfield Prize” and the "Higher Education Prize" for a young faculty member, awarded by the National Council for Higher Education. Living in the sublime and peripheral Upper Galilee, it is perhaps not surprising that I study the concepts of locality, heterogeneity, collaboration, and group-individual interaction, as they shape values and practices in ecology, evolution and community-academia partnership. Noticing the latter led to the co-creation of “Town-Square Academia” in 2011. It teems volunteering academic and local experts, which co-lead short courses and long-term research projects in an effort to discover and disseminate knowledge, enhance dialogues among dissenting groups and worldviews, and resist injustice. While participating, I try to articulate and examine a communal academic model, which will hopefully combine the values of excellence with relevance. 

Accordion Title Areas of Interest

Areas of Interest

Science-Society Interaction,  Community Science, Philosophy of Science, Philosophy of Ecology, Group Selection and  Evolutionary Transitions 

Accordion Title Research

Research

  • Involved Philosophy: the objective is to galvanize, test and explicate a pro-active and multidisciplinary line of research (‘Involved Academia’), which will study constitutive scientific concepts and destabilize borders and hierarchies within and between the academia and the local community (for example, see details on ‘Town Square Academia’).
  • Philosophy of Science: a study of the intersection between biological facts, values, databases and the different meanings of fundamental scientific concepts: ‘location’, ‘space’, ‘time’ and ‘replication’. A localized history of these concepts is needed, e.g. how they are recorded, archived and transformed into working protocols, in order to better understand these concepts and how scientific theory and practice intertwine.
  • Evolution of Cooperation: A study of the different meaning of ‘group’, ‘collectivity’ and ‘individuality’ in evolutionary debates, their link to interactive models (e.g. 'developmental scaffolding", ‘niche construction’) and the history of images and ideologies linked to the debates over the evolution of altruism and cooperation.
  • Biodiversity Conservation: a study of how eco-social 'difference' and 'diversity' is recorded and conserved in biodiversity hotspots, and examining the role of ‘local knowledge’ in changing standard ecological methodology, models  and science-based conservation policy.
Accordion Title Teaching

Teaching

Sample Courses: 

Conflict, Cooperation and Competition", Dep. of Philosophy and the Center for Population Biology, The University of California at Davis, CA U.S.A., Undergraduate seminar
"Introduction to Philosophy of Science", "Evolution and Society", "Science and Values", "Altruism", Philosophy Program, Dep. of Multidisciplinary Studies, Undergraduate courses, Tel-Hai College, 
"Biodiversity: theoretical and practical dimensions", "Basic Concepts in Evolution" Dep. of Environmental Sciences, Undergraduate courses, Tel-Hai College, 
“Philosophy of Science for Social Workers”, Dep. of Social Work”, graduate courses, Tel-Hai College, 
“Critical Theories of Education”, Dep. of Education, graduate course, Tel-Hai College
“Introduction to Action-Oriented Philosophy”, “Identity”, “Academia-Field Collaboration: An International, Interdisciplinary and Action-Oriented Workshop in Athens” Dep. of Action-Oriented Philosophy, graduate courses, Tel Hai College

Accordion Title Awards

Awards

2025     “Van Leer Prize” for a literary essay, awarded by Van Leer Institute, Israel

2024     “PSA outreach and engagement Award”, received by the Philosophy of Science Association (PSA), New Orleans, LA, USA

2018 "Higher Education Prize" for a young faculty member, awarded by the Israeli Council for Higher Education, Israel

2007 "Honourable Mention of Excellence", for post-doctoral research, awarded by the University of California at Davis, CA USA

2006      Marie Currie Fellowship for outgoing international scholars (OIF), EU FP-6

2005      Fulbright Foundation scholarship for post-doctoral research

2004   "Bloomfield Prize" awarded by The Hebrew University for the number one Ph.D. thesis in the faculties of Humanities and Social Sciences, Jerusalem, Israel
*Four times recipient of "Lecturer of Distinction”, awarded by Tel Hai College
 

Accordion Title Publications

Publications

Books and Edited Books: 

Shavit, A. One for All? Facts and Values in the Debate over the Evolution of Altruism" (Jerusalem: Magnes Press, 2008. In Hebrew). 

Shavit A. and Ellison A.R. (eds.) Stepping in the Same River Twice: Replication in Biological Research (New Haven: Yale University Press, 2017). 

Gisis, S., Lamm E. and Shavit A. (eds.) Landscapes of Collectivity in the Life Sciences (The MIT Press, 2018) 

 

 Sample Articles in Peer-Refereed Journals: 

Shavit, A. 2004, "Shifting Values Partly Explain the Debate Over Group Selection", Studies in Histor 

y and Philosophy of Biological and Biomedical Sciences 35: 697-720. 

Shavit, A. 2005, "The Notion of Group and Tests of Group Selection", Philosophy of Science 72: 1052-1063. 

Shavit, A. and Millstein R.L. 2008, “Group Selection is Dead. Long Live Group Selection?” Bioscience 58: 574-578. 

Shavit, A. and Griesemer R. James, 2009, “There and Back, or, The Problem of Locality in Biodiversity Research” Philosophy of Science 76: 273-294. 

Shavit A. and Silver Y. 2016, “To Infinity and Beyond!” Inner Tensions in Global Knowledge- Infrastructures Promote Local and Pro-active ‘Location’ Information”, Science and Technology Studies 29 (4): 31-49. 

Shavit A. 2016, “’Location’ Incommensurability and ‘Replication’ Indeterminacy: Clarifying an Entrenched Conflation by Using an Involved Approach”, Perspectives on Science 24: 425-442 

Shavit, A., and Griesemer R. 2017, "Science and Sentiment: Grinnell's Fact-Based Philosophy of Biodiversity Conservation", Journal of the History of Biology (DOI: 10.1007/s10739-017-9489-4). 

Carmel, Y., and Shavit A. 2020, “Operationalizing Fraternal Transitions in Individuality”, Proceedings of the Royal Society B 287 (1920): 20192805 

Shavit, A. and Ellison A.M. 2021. “Diverse Populations Are Conflated with Heterogeneous Collectives”, Journal of Philosophy 118 (10): 525-548. 

Shavit A. and Silver Y. 2022. “Scientific Excellence and Community Relevance: Can we Have it All?”, Public Understanding of Science 31: 314-322 

Griesemer J.R. and Shavit A. 2023. “Scaffolding Individuality: Coordination, Cooperation, Collaboration and Community”, Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society B, 378: 20210398 

Shavit A. and Sharon G. 2023. “Can Models of Evolutionary Transition Clarify the Debates over the Neolithic Revolution?”, Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society B, 378: 20210413 

Atias, O., Kali Y., Shavit A. and Baram-Tsabari A., 2023. “Meaningful Participation of Schools in Scientific Research Through Contributory Citizen Science Projects”, Science Education 107 (5): 1163-1192.  

Atias, O., Baram-Tsabari A., Kali Y., and Shavit A. 2023. “In Pursuit of Mutual Benefits in school-based Citizen Science: Who Wins What in a Win-Win Situation?”, Instructional Science 51: 695-728. 

Silver Y. and Shavit A. 2025. “Does Diversity Promote Exclusion? “ Studies in the History and Philosophy of Science (Accepted for Publication) 

 

Sample Book Chapters:  

Shavit, A, “Is Nietzsche Present in the Kibbutz’s Education System?” In J Golomb (ed.), Nietzsche, Zionism and Hebrew Culture (Jerusalem: Magnes Press, 2001. Hebrew) 

Shavit A. and Ellison A.R. 2017, “A Taxonomy of Replication”, In A. Shavit A. and A.R. Ellison (eds.), Stepping in the Same River Twice: Replication in Biological Research, New Haven: Yale University Press. 

Helm B. and Shavit A. “Deconstructing and Reconstructing Space and Time in Biological Research” In A. Shavit A. and A.R. Ellison (eds.), Stepping in the Same River Twice: Replication in Biological Research (New Haven: Yale University Press, 2017). 

Shavit A., Kolombus A. and Silver Y. “Collectives, Robustness and Epistemic Injustice” In S. Gisis, Shavit A. and Lamm E (eds.), Landscapes of Collectivity (Cambridge Massachusetts: MIT Press. 2018). 

Shavit, A. and Griesemer J.R. “Transforming Objects into Data: How Minute Technicalities of Recording Species Location Entrench a Basic Theoretical Challenge for Biodiversity”, re-published in M. Dietrich, S. Leonelli and R. Ankeny (eds.), Scaffolding: Selected Contributions of James R. Griesemer to History, Philosophy, and Biology (London: Springer). 

 

Accordion Title Prof. Ayelet Shavit CV

Prof. Ayelet Shavit CV